No magnets needed: Extreme voltage drives completely new kind of Hall effect

Rice physicists describe fully nonequilibrium effect that mimics behavior in magnetic field

two versions of the electron momentum space; one is shifted far to the right. See text for details.

The Hall effect, a physical phenomenon in which a current arises perpendicular to a voltage applied across a material, has been of particular interest to physicists since it was discovered more than a century ago. Over time, physicists have broadened their understanding of the Hall effect, describing quantum and anomalous versions that appear under nonclassical conditions. Recently, Rice University’s Qimiao Si published a paper in Physical Review Letters describing a new variant called the fully nonequilibrium response that once again expands how physicists understand the Hall effect.

“Our work epitomizes how research often spirals upward,” said Si, the Harry C. and Olga K. Wiess Professor of Physics and Astronomy, director of Rice’s Extreme Quantum Materials Alliance and corresponding author on this study. “It can be traced back to a theoretical proposal for a strongly correlated topological semimetal state that my group advanced previously.”

Si and collaborators at the Technical University of Vienna studied a material realization of this strongly correlated topological semimetal state. Part of their work included studying the Hall effect in this material, which both gave them key information and opened up new questions.

An Asian man smiles at the camera.
Qimiao Si

“The Hall measurement provided evidence for the basic tenet of the topological state,” Si said. “While that validation was gratifying, the experiment turned up something puzzling on its own.”

In the classical Hall effect, a voltage is run through a metal in a magnetic field and a current is generated in a direction perpendicular to voltage. The presence of a magnetic field breaks the time reversal symmetry (TRS). That is, if a magnetic field is present, some of the material’s characteristics will change over time, meaning that the past and future states are no longer symmetrical. If an external magnetic field or internal magnetism is absent, researchers would expect TRS, where the past and future states mirror each other.

In the quantum anomalous Hall effect, a voltage run through a material causes the same perpendicular current, but it does so without the presence of an external magnetic field. Instead, TRS breaking happens through the internal magnetism of the materials.

“We can measure TRS breaking by comparing voltage to current,” said Shouvik Sur, a former Rice postdoctoral fellow and the first author on this study. “Generally, if the two are proportional, there will be a linear relationship and we assume there is TRS breaking. However, if the voltage is proportional to current squared, which produces a nonlinear relationship, TRS remains unbroken.”

The data the team looked at from the topological semimetal material showed it was generating a perpendicular current to a voltage, where the current was proportional to the voltage: an indication of TRS breaking. But this semimetal didn’t have an internal magnetic field, and there was no external magnetic field applied. So why was the data showing evidence of TRS breaking?

“This is where experimentalists and theorists collaborate in an especially rewarding way,” Si said. “We theorists are always happy to see experimental data in support of our ideas. But if the data revealed a further puzzle, we have the chance to build new frameworks that allow for further understandings.”

When the team considered the Hall effect of the topological semimetal state closely, they found that its quantum nonlinear anomalous Hall effect could actually have a two-stage response. In the first stage, with a weak voltage, the effect behaved as expected with the voltage proportional to the current squared. But as the voltage increased, the material could enter into a second stage, which mimicked breaking of TRS. In that stage, the electrons temporarily acquire extra momentum due to the applied voltage, and the current becomes directly proportional to the voltage. However, the state is only temporary: Once the voltage drops back down, it returns to its former state showing TRS. Where this bend, or transition point is, Sur explained, depends on the material in question. Some transition at a very low voltage; others at a higher voltage. They called this fully nonequilibrium response.

A graphic showing the electrons moving in their momentum space. See text for details.
Left: The electron momentum space under weak voltage. Right, the electron momentum space shifts under high voltage. Credit: Rice University/Shouvic Sur. 
An Indian man smiles at the camera
Shouvik Sur. Credit: Shouvic Sur.

“What’s interesting about these results is that our understanding of the Hall effect was originally based on what we call equilibrium physics, where external forces on a system, like voltage, are rather weak,” Sur said. “Now, we are looking at a system that is not in equilibrium due to a strong external force, and it is responding to changes in this force. This is a much harder thing to understand. Here, we found something that can look like magnetism in an equilibrium system, something we understand quite well, but it is not magnetism and it is not in an equilibrium system.”

The study brought new insights into the quantum nonlinear Hall effect in a nonequilibrium state, but it also sheds new light on the physics of topological semimetals in equilibrium.

“Our work supports the existence of a strongly correlated topological semimetal state,” Si said. “It demonstrates how studying nonequilibrium quantum phenomena can deepen our understanding of quantum states of matter in equilibrium.”

The work at Rice was funded by the National Science Foundation (DMR-2220603), the Robert A. Welch Foundation (C-1411) and the Vannevar Bush Faculty Fellowship (ONR-VB N00014-23-1-2870).

Body