Physicists find first possible 3D quantum spin liquid

David Ruth
713-348-6327
david@rice.edu

Jade Boyd
713-348-6778
jadeboyd@rice.edu

Physicists find first possible 3D quantum spin liquid

Cerium pyrochlore is first to qualify as long-sought state of matter

HOUSTON — (July 15, 2019) — There’s no known way to prove a three-dimensional “quantum spin liquid” exists, so Rice University physicists and their collaborators did the next best thing: They showed their single crystals of cerium zirconium pyrochlore had the right stuff to qualify as the first possible 3D version of the long-sought state of matter.

Rice University physicists Tong Chen, Pengcheng Dai, David Tam, Andriy Nevidomskyy, Bin Gao and Emilia Morosan

Rice University physicists (from left) Tong Chen, Pengcheng Dai, David Tam, Andriy Nevidomskyy, Bin Gao and Emilia Morosan are co-authors of a Nature Physics study that found single crystals of cerium zirconium pyrochlore to be the first possible 3D quantum spin liquid, a material first theorized in 1973. (Photo by Jeff Fitlow/Rice University)

Despite the name, a quantum spin liquid is a solid material in which the weird property of quantum mechanics — entanglement — ensures a liquidlike magnetic state.

In a paper this week in Nature Physics, researchers offered a host of experimental evidence — including crucial neutron-scattering experiments at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and muon spin relaxation experiments at Switzerland’s Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI) — to support their case that cerium zirconium pyrochlore, in its single-crystal form, is the first material that qualifies as a 3D quantum spin liquid.

“A quantum spin liquid is something that scientists define based on what you don’t see,” said Rice’s Pengcheng Dai, corresponding author of the study and a member of Rice’s Center for Quantum Materials (RCQM). “You don’t see long-range order in the arrangement of spins. You don’t see disorder. And various other things. It’s not this. It’s not that. There’s no conclusive positive identification.”

The research team’s samples are believed to be the first of their kind: Pyrochlores because of their 2-to-2-to-7 ratio of cerium, zirconium and oxygen, and single crystals because the atoms inside them are arranged in a continuous, unbroken lattice.

“We’ve done every experiment that we could think of on this compound,” Dai said. “(Study co-author) Emilia Morosan‘s group at Rice did heat capacity work to show that the material undergoes no phase transition down to 50 millikelvin. We did very careful crystallography to show there is no disorder in the crystal. We did muon spin relaxation experiments that demonstrated an absence of long-range magnetic order down to 20 millikelvin, and we did diffraction experiments that showed the sample has no oxygen vacancy or other known defects. Finally, we did inelastic neutron scattering that showed the presence of a spin-excitation continuum — which may be a quantum spin liquid hallmark — down to 35 millikelvin.”

Bin Gao at the CORELLI beamline of Oak Ridge National Laboratory's Spallation Neutron Source

Bin Gao, co-lead author of a Nature Physics study about the first possible 3D quantum spin liquid, at the CORELLI beamline of Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s Spallation Neutron Source. (Photo by ORNL/Genevieve Martin)

Dai, a professor of physics and astronomy, credited the success of the study to his colleagues, notably co-lead authors Bin Gao and Tong Chen and co-author David Tam. Gao, a Rice postdoctoral research associate, created the single-crystal samples in a laser floating zone furnace at the lab of Rutgers University co-author Sang-Wook Cheong. Tong, a Rice Ph.D. student, helped Bin perform experiments at ORNL that produced a spin excitation continuum indicative of the presence of spin entanglement that produces short-range order, and Tam, also a Rice Ph.D. student, led muon spin rotation experiments at PSI.

Despite the team’s effort, Dai said it is impossible to definitively say cerium-zirconium 227 is a spin liquid, partly because physicists haven’t yet agreed on what experimental proof is necessary to make the declaration, and partly because the definition of a quantum spin liquid is a state that exists at absolute zero temperature, an ideal beyond the reach of any experiment.

Quantum spin liquids are believed to occur in solid materials that are composed of magnetic atoms in particular crystalline arrangements. The inherent property of electrons that leads to magnetism is spin, and electron spins can only point up or down. In most materials, spins are shuffled at random like a deck of cards, but magnetic materials are different. In the magnets on refrigerators and inside MRI machines, spins sense their neighbors and arrange themselves collectively in one direction. Physicists call this “long-range ferromagnetic order,” and another important example of long-range magnetic order is antiferromagnetism, where spins collectively arrange in a repeating, up-down, up-down pattern.

A 3D representation of the spin-excitation continuum of cerium zirconium pyrochlore

A 3D representation of the spin-excitation continuum — a possible hallmark of a quantum spin liquid — observed in a single crystal sample of cerium zirconium pyrochlore in experiments at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). Inelastic neutron-scattering experiments at ORNL’s Spallation Neutron Source revealed spin-excitation continua in samples of cerium zirconium pyrochlore that were cooled as low 35 millikelvin. (Image by Tong Chen/Rice University)

“In a solid with a periodic arrangement of spins, if you know what a spin is doing over here, you can know what a spin is doing many, many repetitions away because of long-range order,” said Rice theoretical physicist and study co-author Andriy Nevidomskyy, an associate professor of physics and astronomy and RCQM member. “In a liquid, on the other hand, there is no long-range order. If you look at two molecules of water a millimeter apart, for example, there is no correlation whatsoever. Nevertheless, due to their hydrogen-hydrogen bonds, they can still have an ordered arrangement at very short distances with nearby molecules, which would be an example of short-range order.”

In 1973, Nobel laureate physicist Philip Anderson proposed the idea of quantum spin liquids based upon the realization that that geometric arrangement of atoms in some crystals could make it impossible for entangled spins to collectively orient themselves in stable arrangements.

As noted science writer Philip Ball aptly described in 2017, “Imagine an antiferromagnet — in which adjacent spins prefer to be oppositely oriented — on a triangular lattice. Each spin has two nearest neighbors in a triangle, but the antiparallel alignment cannot be satisfied for all of the trio. One possibility is that the spin lattice freezes into a disordered ‘glassy’ state, but Anderson showed that quantum mechanics allows the possibility of fluctuating spins even at absolute zero (temperature). This state is called a quantum spin liquid, and Anderson later suggested that it might be connected to high-temperature superconductivity.”

The possibility that quantum spin liquids might explain high-temperature superconductivity spurred widespread interest among condensed matter physicists since the 1980s, and Nevidomskyy said interest further increased when it was “suggested that some examples of so-called topological quantum spin liquids may be amenable to building qubits” for quantum computing.

Physicists Huibo Cao, Bin Gao, Gabriele Sala, Feng Ye and Matt Stone at the CORELLI beamline of ORNL's Spallation Neutron Source

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) instrument scientist Huibo Cao, Rice University postdoctoral researcher Bin Gao and ORNL instrument scientists Gabriele Sala, Feng Ye and Matt Stone at the CORELLI beamline of ORNL’s Spallation Neutron Source. (Photo by ORNL/Genevieve Martin)

“But I believe part of the curiosity about quantum spin liquids is that it has resurfaced in many incarnations and theoretical proposals,” he said. “And although we have theoretical models where we know, for a fact, that the result will be a spin liquid, finding an actual physical material that would fulfill those properties has, so far, proven very difficult. There is no consensus in the field, up to now, that any material — 2D or 3D — is a quantum spin liquid.”

Morosan is a professor of physics and astronomy, chemistry, and materials science and nanoengineering at Rice and a member of RCQM.

RCQM leverages global partnerships and the strengths of more than 20 Rice research groups to address questions related to quantum materials. RCQM is supported by Rice’s offices of the provost and the vice provost for research, the Wiess School of Natural Sciences, the Brown School of Engineering, the Smalley-Curl Institute and the departments of Physics and Astronomy, Electrical and Computer Engineering, and Materials Science and NanoEngineering.

Additional study co-authors include Chien-Lung Huang and Haoyu Hu of Rice; Kalyan Sasmal and Brian Maple, both of the University of California, San Diego; Devashibhai Adroja of the United Kingdom’s Rutherford-Appleton Laboratory; Feng Ye, Huibo Cao, Gabriele Sala and Matthew Stone, all of the Neutron Scattering Division at ORNL; Christopher Baines and Joel Barker, both of PSI; Jae-Ho Chung of both Rice and Korea University, Seoul; Xianghan Xu of Rutgers; Manivannan Nallaiyan and Stefano Spagna, both of Quantum Designs Inc. in San Diego; and Gang Chen of both the University of Hong Kong and Fudan University, Shanghai.

The research was supported by the Department of Energy (BES DE-SC0012311, BES DE-SC0019503, BES DE-FG02-04ER46105, BES KC0402010 and DE-AC05-00OR22725), the Robert A. Welch Foundation (C-1839 and C-1818), the National Science Foundation (DMR-1350237), the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF-2017K1A3A7A09016303), Rutgers University, the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation’s EPiQS initiative (GBMF6402) and the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (2016YFA0301001 and 2016YFA0300500).

-30-

High-resolution IMAGES are available for download at:

https://news.rice.edu/files/2019/07/0715_CE227-sec1-lg.jpg
CAPTION: A 3D representation of the spin-excitation continuum — a possible hallmark of a quantum spin liquid — observed in a single crystal sample of cerium zirconium pyrochlore in experiments at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). Inelastic neutron-scattering experiments at ORNL’s Spallation Neutron Source revealed spin-excitation continua in samples of cerium zirconium pyrochlore that were cooled as low 35 millikelvin. (Image by Tong Chen/Rice University)

https://news.rice.edu/files/2019/07/0715_CE227-rgp2-lg.jpg
CAPTION: Rice University physicists (from left) Tong Chen, Pengcheng Dai, David Tam, Andriy Nevidomskyy, Bin Gao and Emilia Morosan are co-authors of a Nature Physics study that found single crystals of cerium zirconium pyrochlore to be the first possible 3D quantum spin liquid, a material first theorized in 1973. (Photo by Jeff Fitlow/Rice University)

https://news.rice.edu/files/2019/07/0715_CE227-ornl61R-lg.jpg
CAPTION: Bin Gao, co-lead author of a Nature Physics study about the first possible 3D quantum spin liquid, at the CORELLI beamline of Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s Spallation Neutron Source. (Photo by ORNL/Genevieve Martin)

https://news.rice.edu/files/2019/07/0715_CE227-ornl56r-lg.jpg
CAPTION: (left to right) Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) instrument scientist Huibo Cao, Rice University postdoctoral researcher Bin Gao and ORNL instrument scientists Gabriele Sala, Feng Ye and Matt Stone at the CORELLI beamline of ORNL’s Spallation Neutron Source. (Photo by ORNL/Genevieve Martin)

Related materials:

The DOI of the Nature Physics paper is: 10.1038/s41567-019-0577-6

A copy of the paper is available at: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0577-6.

Pengcheng Dai: pdai.phys.rice.edu

Andriy Nevidomskyy: physics.rice.edu/people/andriy-nevidomskyy

Emilia Morosan: morosan.rice.edu

Rice Department of Physics and Astronomy: physics.rice.edu

Wiess School of Natural Sciences: naturalsciences.rice.edu

Related research from Rice:

Superconductor’s magnetic persona unmasked — May 20, 2019
https://news.rice.edu/2019/05/20/superconductors-magnetic-persona-unmasked-2/

Quirky kindred compounds could crack quantum code — Dec. 20, 2018
https://news.rice.edu/2018/12/20/quirky-kindred-compounds-could-crack-quantum-code/

‘Magnetic topological insulator’ makes its own magnetic field — Nov. 19, 2018
http://news.rice.edu/2018/11/19/magnetic-topological-insulator-makes-its-own-magnetic-field%E2%80%A8/

Rice U. physicists discover new type of quantum material — Dec. 18, 2017
http://news.rice.edu/2017/12/18/rice-u-physicists-discover-new-type-of-quantum-material-2/

A superconductor story with a twist — Aug. 7, 2018
http://news.rice.edu/2018/08/07/a-superconductor-story-with-a-twist/

Rules for superconductivity mirrored in ‘excitonic insulator’ — Dec. 7, 2017
http://news.rice.edu/2017/12/07/rules-for-superconductivity-mirrored-in-excitonic-insulator-2/

Copper stripes help iron pnictide lock in insulating state — Dec. 19, 2016
http://news.rice.edu/2016/12/19/copper-stripes-help-iron-pnictide-lock-in-insulating-state-2/

Physicists probe magnetic fluctuations in heavy fermions — Sept. 29, 2016
http://news.rice.edu/2016/09/29/physicists-probe-magnetic-fluctuations-in-heavy-fermion-2/

Titanium + gold = new gold standard for artificial joints — July 20, 2016
http://news.rice.edu/2016/07/20/titanium-gold-new-gold-standard-for-artificial-joints-2/

Study finds physical link to strange electronic behavior — July 31, 2014
http://news.rice.edu/2014/07/31/study-finds-physical-link-to-strange-electronic-behavior/

Located on a 300-acre forested campus in Houston, Rice University is consistently ranked among the nation’s top 20 universities by U.S. News & World Report. Rice has highly respected schools of Architecture, Business, Continuing Studies, Engineering, Humanities, Music, Natural Sciences and Social Sciences and is home to the Baker Institute for Public Policy. With 3,962 undergraduates and 3,027 graduate students, Rice’s undergraduate student-to-faculty ratio is just under 6-to-1. Its residential college system builds close-knit communities and lifelong friendships, just one reason why Rice is ranked No. 1 for lots of race/class interaction and No. 2 for quality of life by the Princeton Review. Rice is also rated as a best value among private universities by Kiplinger’s Personal Finance.

About Jade Boyd

Jade Boyd is science editor and associate director of news and media relations in Rice University's Office of Public Affairs.