Boron atoms stretch out, gain new powers

Editor’s note: Links to videos and high-resolution images for download appear at the end of this release. 

David Ruth

Mike Williams

Boron atoms stretch out, gain new powers

Rice University simulations demonstrate 1-D material’s stiffness, electrical versatility 

HOUSTON – (Jan. 26, 2017) – Hold on, there, graphene. You might think you’re the most interesting new nanomaterial of the century, but boron might already have you beat, according to scientists at Rice University.

A Rice team that simulated one-dimensional forms of boron — both two-atom-wide ribbons and single-atom chains — found they possess unique properties. The new findings appear this week in the Journal of the American Chemical Society.

For example, if metallic ribbons of boron are stretched, they morph into antiferromagnetic semiconducting chains, and when released they fold back into ribbons.

A truss-like ribbon of boron atoms transforms as it stretches into a carbyne-like chain, also going from a semiconductor to metallic conductor, according to Rice University scientists. In this simulation, the one-dimensional chain is stretched to the breaking point. Courtesy of the Yakobson Group

The 1-D boron materials also have mechanical stiffness on a par with the highest-performing known nanomaterials.

And they can act as nanoscale, constant-force springs.

Experimental labs are making progress in synthesizing atom-thin and fullerene-type boron, which led Rice researcher Boris Yakobson to think 1-D boron may eventually become real as well.

Yakobson’s lab creates atom-level computer simulations of materials that do not necessarily exist — yet. Simulating and testing their energetic properties helps guide experimentalists working to create real-world materials. Carbon-atom chains known as carbyne, boron fullerenes and two-dimensional films called borophene, all predicted by the Rice group, have since been created by labs.

“Our work on carbyne and with planar boron got us thinking that a one-dimensional chain of boron atoms is also a possible and intriguing structure,” Yakobson said. “We wanted to know if it is stable and what the properties would be. That’s where modern theoretical-computational methods are impressive, because one can do pretty realistic assessments of non-existing structures.

In this simulation, the one-dimensional chain is stretched to the breaking point. Courtesy of the Yakobson Group

“Even if they never exist, they’re still important since we’re probing the limits of possibility, sort of the final frontier,” he said.

One-dimensional boron forms two well-defined phases — chains and ribbons — which are linked by a “reversible phase transition,” meaning they can turn from one form to the other and back.

To demonstrate these interesting chemomechanics, the researchers used a computer to “pull” the ends of a simulated boron ribbon with 64 atoms. This forced the atoms to rearrange into a single carbyne-like chain. In their simulation, the researchers left a fragment of the ribbon to serve as a seed, and when they released the tension, the atoms from the chain neatly returned to ribbon form.

“Boron is very different from carbon,” Yakobson said. “It prefers to form a double row of atoms, like a truss used in bridge construction. This appears to be the most stable, lowest-energy state.

“If you pull on it, it starts unfolding; the atoms yield to this monatomic thread. And if you release the force, it folds back,” he said. “That’s quite fun, structurally, and at the same time it changes the electronic properties.

“That makes it an interesting combination: When you stretch it halfway, you may have a portion of ribbon and a portion of chain. Because one of them is metal and the other is a semiconductor, this becomes a one-dimensional, adjustable Schottky junction.” A Schottky junction is a barrier to electrons at a metal-semiconductor junction and is commonly used in diodes that allow current to flow in only one direction.

As a ribbon, boron is “a true 1-D metal robust to distortion of its crystalline lattice (a property known as Peierls distortion),” the researchers wrote. That truss-like construct gives the material extraordinary stiffness, a measure of its ability to resist deformation from an applied force.

As a chain of atoms, the material is also a strain-tunable, wide-gap antiferromagnetic semiconductor. In an antiferromagnet, the atomic moments — the direction of the atoms’ “up” or “down” spin states — align in opposite directions. This coupling of magnetic state and electronic transport may be of great interest to researchers studying spintronics, in which spin states may be manipulated to create high-performance electronic devices. “It may be very useful because instead of charge transport, you can have spin transport. That’s considered an important direction for devices that make use of spintronics,” he said.

One-dimensional boron’s springiness is also interesting, Yakobson said. “It’s also a special spring, a constant-force spring,” he said. “The more you stretch a mechanical spring, the more the force goes up. But in the case of 1-D boron, the same force is required until the spring becomes fully stretched. If you keep pulling, it will break. But if you release the force, it completely folds back into a ribbon. It’s a mechanically nice structure.” That property could be useful in nanoscale sensors to gauge very small forces, he said.

Rice alumna Mingjie Liu, now a research associate at Brookhaven National Laboratory, is lead author of the paper. Vasilii Artyukhov, also a Rice alumnus and now a research scientist at Quantlab Financial, is co-author. Yakobson is the Karl F. Hasselmann Professor of Materials Science and NanoEngineering and a professor of chemistry.

The Office of Naval Research and the Robert Welch Foundation supported the research. Calculations were performed on Rice’s National Science Foundation-supported DAVinCI supercomputer, which was administered by Rice’s Center for Research Computing and procured in partnership with the Ken Kennedy Institute for Information Technology.


Read the abstract at

Follow Rice News and Media Relations via Twitter @RiceUNews





A truss-like ribbon of boron atoms transforms as it stretches into a carbyne-like chain, also going from a semiconductor to metallic conductor, according to Rice University scientists. In this simulation, the one-dimensional chain is stretched to the breaking point. (Credit: Yakobson Group/Rice University)




In this simulation, the one-dimensional chain turns back into a ribbon as tension is released. (Credit: Yakobson Group/Rice University)

Related materials:

Yakobson Research Group:

Rice University Department of Materials Science and NanoEngineering:

George R. Brown School of Engineering:

Images for download:



Stills from a simulation of the properties of one-dimensional boron shows the material that starts as a ribbon transforms into a single-atom chain, until it reaches the breaking point. Rice University scientists discovered the still-theoretical material would have unique electrical and mechanical properties. (Credit: Yakobson Group/Rice University)




A simulation of one-dimensional boron under stress shows the theoretical material changing phase from a ribbon to a chain of atoms when pulled. The chain returns to ribbon form when the stress is relieved. (Credit: Yakobson Group/Rice University)

One-dimensional boron, investigated by theoretical physicists at Rice University, could be a unique material that incorporates both a semiconductor (the ribbon portion) and a metallic conductor (the single-atom chain). Because it can transform from one form to the other under stress, the material could form an adjustable Schottky junction. (Credit: Yakobson Group/Rice University)

Located on a 300-acre forested campus in Houston, Rice University is consistently ranked among the nation’s top 20 universities by U.S. News & World Report. Rice has highly respected schools of Architecture, Business, Continuing Studies, Engineering, Humanities, Music, Natural Sciences and Social Sciences and is home to the Baker Institute for Public Policy. With 3,910 undergraduates and 2,809 graduate students, Rice’s undergraduate student-to-faculty ratio is 6-to-1. Its residential college system builds close-knit communities and lifelong friendships, just one reason why Rice is ranked No. 1 for happiest students and for lots of race/class interaction by the Princeton Review. Rice is also rated as a best value among private universities by Kiplinger’s Personal Finance. To read “What they’re saying about Rice,” go to

About Mike Williams

Mike Williams is a senior media relations specialist in Rice University's Office of Public Affairs.