Rice wins $2.4M to study many-antenna wireless

David Ruth

Mike Williams

Rice wins $2.4M to study many-antenna wireless

Rice-led project will investigate ‘beamforming’ base stations with hundreds of antennas

HOUSTON — (Nov. 24, 2015) — Rice University researchers have won $2.4 million from the National Science Foundation (NSF) to conduct the most extensive experimental research yet of wireless technology that uses 100 or more antennas per base station to send tightly focused beams of data to each user, even as they move.

The research at Rice’s campus in Houston will help the wireless industry determine whether and how to include the many-antenna technology — known in industry parlance as “massive multi-user, multi-input multi-output,” or massive MU-MIMO — in upcoming 5G wireless standards.

“Early tests of many-antenna technology at Rice and elsewhere suggest that wireless carriers could use this technology to serve many times more data than can be served with today’s 4G networks,” said Lin Zhong, associate professor of electrical and computer engineering and of computer science at Rice and the principal investigator on the new grant. “But there are still many questions about how to scale this technology for real-world implementation. Those are the challenges we’ll be tackling with the new research.”

The research will make use of ArgosNet, a many-antenna experimental test bed that Zhong’s Efficient Computing Group is building thanks to a 2014 NSF infrastructure grant. ArgosNet will eventually include up to a half-dozen programmable base stations, each with 100 or more antennas. Zhong’s team will be able to reconfigure each to emulate cell-tower base stations or other types of wireless network nodes. The many-antenna technology being investigated leverages a large number of base station antennas to serve many users at the same time. When the number of base station antennas is significantly larger than the number of users, the technology is also referred to as “massive MIMO.”

Rice ArgosNet wireless testbed base station

Rice University's Argos Network will use base stations with more than 100 antennas apiece to share spectrum by beaming information directly to many users simultaneously on the same frequency. Credit: Jeff Fitlow/Rice University

“Large-scale multi-user MIMO technology is a key enabler in meeting the 1,000x data challenge — that of increasing spectrum efficiency by a factor of 1,000 when compared to current 4G data networks,” said NSF Program Director Thyaga Nandagopal. “The National Science Foundation has funded basic research in this area for several years now, and this project will advance this research to the next level by addressing the system-level challenges that can hinder the realization of this technology’s full potential.”

Today’s top-of-the-line 4G wireless data networks serve data to millions, but each base station only communicates with up to four users at a time on a given frequency. They appear to serve thousands simultaneously by dividing their time and frequency to serve tiny slices of data to each user every few milliseconds. Ideally, users never notice they are sharing the network, but data rates can slow if too many users are online at once, and based on industry trends, slowdowns will become more common.

According to a 2014 study by Cisco, wireless carriers increased the average mobile network downstream speed from 1,387 kilobits per second (kbps) in 2013 to 1,683 kbps in 2014. That’s a notable improvement, but nowhere near the growth that is needed to meet demand. The same report found that smartphones generated 22 times more demand for mobile data than did nonsmart devices, and 88 percent of the 497 million new mobile devices added worldwide in 2014 were smart.

Lin Zhong (standing) and Clayton Shepard with ArgosNet base station.

Lin Zhong (standing) and Clayton Shepard with ArgosNet base station.

Zhong said the new experimental research with ArgosNet, which draws its name from the many-eyed giant of Greek mythology, could provide the answer that wireless carriers need for the coming bandwidth crunch. ArgosNet uses its many antennas to beam information directly to numerous users simultaneously on the same frequency. It does this by constantly computing where each user is and altering the signal to each antenna to direct a focused beam directly to each user.

The payoff can be enormous, because carriers can use limited frequency bands to serve many more users, but there are also complications. The computing power needed to both track users and continuously form and re-form beams in real time is significant, Zhong said. There are also issues related to interference because each wireless device must regularly broadcast so that the base station knows where to focus the beams.

Among the ArgosNet team members is Clayton Shepard, a Ph.D. student who is building the ArgosNet base stations and mobile clients, and who’s already worked with NASA to test massive MIMO designs using specialized facilities that were originally built to test spacecraft communications systems.

“ArgosNet is a very flexible platform,” Shepard said. “We’ve designed it to work like Lego blocks; we can add or subtract antennas and other components to construct any kind of node that we want. The wireless test units also can be configured to act like everything from a laptop to a wireless handset.”

Proposed map for ArgosNet tests at Rice

Researchers from Rice University have won a $2.4 million federal grant to conduct tests of many-antenna wireless technology on the university's campus. Credit: C. Shepherd/Rice University

Shepard said the flexibility will allow the newly funded project team to evaluate the overhead computing demands for beam-forming, interference from pilot signal traffic, as well as how MU-MIMO might be co-implemented with “densification,” another potential 5G technology that calls for deploying many more base stations to make the best possible use of limited radio spectrum.

“MU-MIMO will almost certainly be included in the specifications for 5G, but no one knows how many antennas to call for because the trade-offs between cost, size, power and performance haven’t been determined,” Shepard said. “We’ll be able to evaluate each of these and answer other questions about how to implement this technology in the real world.”

Shepard said the team is exploring how to make ArgosNet compatible with existing smartphones and wireless devices, but the current base stations are not compatible with existing technology. For Rice’s tests, Shepard and other members of Zhong’s team will use reprogrammable, battery-powered test units.

The project team includes Rice’s Edward Knightly, professor and department chair of electrical and computer engineering and director of the Rice Wireless Network Group; Rice’s Ashutosh Sabharwal, professor of electrical and computer engineering; and Ohio State University’s Ness Shroff, the Ohio Eminent Scholar in Networking and Communications and professor of electrical and computer engineering and of computer science and engineering.


VIDEO is available at:
High-resolution IMAGES are available for download at:

CAPTION: Rice University researchers will use many-antenna base stations with more than 100 antennas apiece in a 5G wireless test network in Houston on the university’s campus.
CREDIT: Jeff Fitlow/Rice University

CAPTION: Rice University’s Argos Network, a 5G wireless test bed, will use base stations with more than 100 antennas apiece to share spectrum by beaming information directly to many users simultaneously on the same frequency.
CREDIT: Jeff Fitlow/Rice University

CAPTION: Researchers from Rice University have won a $2.4 million federal grant to build a first-of-its-kind test bed for 5G wireless technology in Houston on the university’s campus.
CREDIT: C. Shepard/Rice University

Lin Zhong (standing) and Clayton Shepard with ArgosNet base station.
CREDIT: D. Soward/Rice University

More information about Argos is available at:

ArgosNet homepage:

NSF grant award:

Related wireless research from Rice:

Rice tests wireless data delivery over active TV channels — July 13, 2015

Wireless experts tap unused TV spectrum — Sept. 9, 2014

How to feed data hungry mobile devices? Use more antennas — Aug. 23, 2012

ArgosNet is designed to feed data-hungry smartphones

Rice breakthrough could double wireless capacity with no new towers — Sept. 7, 2011

Rice breakthrough could double wireless capacity with no new towers

Wireless at WARP speed — Jan. 29, 2009

Located on a 300-acre forested campus in Houston, Rice University is consistently ranked among the nation’s top 20 universities by U.S. News & World Report. Rice has highly respected schools of Architecture, Business, Continuing Studies, Engineering, Humanities, Music, Natural Sciences and Social Sciences and is home to the Baker Institute for Public Policy. With 3,910 undergraduates and 2,809 graduate students, Rice’s undergraduate student-to-faculty ratio is 6-to-1. Its residential college system builds close-knit communities and lifelong friendships, just one reason why Rice is ranked No. 1 for best quality of life and for lots of race/class interaction by the Princeton Review. Rice is also rated as a best value among private universities by Kiplinger’s Personal Finance. To read “What they’re saying about Rice,” go to http://tinyurl.com/AboutRiceUniversity.

About Jade Boyd

Jade Boyd is science editor and associate director of news and media relations in Rice University's Office of Public Affairs.